Hi - I've provided feedback for everyone. My approach has been to make suggestions about what particular aspects I think would make it better.

I'm big on the CRAP philosophy of design.

C -> Consistency
R -> Repetition
A -> Alignment
P -> Proximity

A little more detail here:
C.R.A.P Design - Cre8asite Forums

Google "crap design" to find more.

Quite often a few CRAP changes, and the logos submitted will look much better.

Overdoing drop shadows, fading, or having too much going on will be big negatives.

Jagged edges, or lack of crispness is a big no-no. If you're using Photoshop instead of a vector based software, you should design the logo at a higher resolution and try reducing it to the final dimensions to get a higher quality output.

In general, 2 to 4 colors is best. There have been some good entries with more color, but I lean towards reduced colors in a quality logo suitable for multiple purposes from Web to print.

__________________
Joe Ward / vBHackers.com
vBSEO 3.2.0 Launched - Maximum Overdrive for Your Web Traffic! Over 100 Instant SEO Optimizations

vBSEO Google Sitemap Generator - Version 2.2 Released Mandatory Upgrade for vBSEO 3.2.0 GOLD

6X Traffic - $1400 in One Day with vBSEO! Imagine What the vBSEO Patent Pending Technology Can Do For You.

Crawlability Network: vBulletin SEO | vBulletin Hackers

Here in the Uk if i was to tell Shelley one of her styles was A CRAP design she would hunt me down and take a hammer to my laptop ha ha ha ...

If you were to tell me my styles were crap I would agree with you. I wouldn't take a hammer to your laptop though. Oh no, I would replace it with the Mac laptop i gave away which I couldn't do of course because I don't have it anymore. :confused:

Interesting Article Joe. I do follow those rules though I do like the drop shadow.

Still a rule that has to be followed.

We owe them that much to give a little feedback. Doesn't take nothing but a second.